In the next few days the French Senate will vote on a copyright reform bill will which will effectively outlaw DRM, as well as bringing more reasonable fines (€38 to €150) for pirating music.
This whole story has been horribly twisted by the US media, being referred to as a war against Apple and iTunes by the New York Times, and state-sponsored piracy by Apple.
How this bill became an attack on Apple at all I don’t know, the iPod isn’t even the dominant portable media player in France, and it targets DRM in general, so everybody is affected equally. With the US expanding the DMCA to increase the maximum prison sentence for attempted piracy to 10 years, there is finally a country setting sensible laws with the consumers, rather than businesses in mind.
Let me make one thing clear: I don’t condone piracy. But I like freedom, and I don’t believe people are predisposed to break the law. Fair use has been steadily eroded over the past few years, and things are only going to get worse in the future. We have a country which has stepped in, and is trying to pass a law with the consumers interests in mind, rather than those of big businesses. Go after pirates, but those who are doing so as a commercial venture. Don’t sue your customers, really. The concept may seem strange, but trust me, it will make sense if you think about it.
Are people going to start sharing all of their music on peer to peer networks because there are no restrictions on them? Only time will tell, but I feel the answer will be a resounding no. There will always be people who will obtain music illegally, but the vast majority of people are law abiding, and this law serves only to make things easier for them.
I for one hope that this bill is passed into law in France. While it will not have any direct effect on me, it will prove an interesting test case, and hopefully politicians in other countries will sit up and take note.